If there's one debate we hear in nearly every bathroom consultation, it's this one. One person wants a sleek walk-in shower. The other person is not giving up their bubble baths without a fight.
Good news: there's no wrong team here. There's just the right choice for your home and the people in it. Here's how we help couples, families, and solo homeowners settle it.
Quick question: when was the last bath?
Be honest. If your tub has mostly become a very large shampoo shelf with a curtain attached, it might be time to let it go. Swapping it for a walk-in shower gives you that space back. It's easier to step into, much easier to clean, and it instantly makes the room feel fresher.
But if you've got little ones who need bath time, or Sunday-night soaks are sacred in your house, keep the tub. Never remove something you'll miss just because it's trendy.
Think about resale (a little)
The common wisdom is that a home should have at least one bathtub somewhere, mostly for families with young kids. If you have more than one full bathroom, converting a tub to a shower is usually no problem. If it's the only tub in the house and you're thinking of selling in the next few years, it's worth a second thought.
Planning to stay put? Then design the bathroom for you. You're the one starting every morning in there.
Look at the space you've got
In a smaller bathroom, a standard tub-shower combo eats up about a 5-foot wall. Turn that into a walk-in shower with clear glass and the whole room seems to take a deep breath. Same footprint, much more open feel.
Got a roomier primary bath? You might not have to pick at all. A generous walk-in shower plus a freestanding soaking tub is one of our favorite combinations. Everyone wins, and the room feels like a little getaway.
Think about future you
A curbless or low-threshold shower is wonderfully easy to use at any age. No tall tub wall to climb over, plus room for a built-in bench and grab bars that blend right into the design. If this is your forever home, future you will be very grateful.
Know what's involved
Turning a tub into a walk-in shower is a little more than a swap. It usually means reworking the drain, waterproofing properly, picking tile and glass, and sometimes moving plumbing. Upgrading to a freestanding tub has its own to-do list, like checking floor support and planning where the faucet goes.
None of that should scare you off. It just means this is a decision best made with someone standing in your actual bathroom.
Let's settle the debate together
At Cumberland Kitchen and Bath, we've built dreamy walk-in showers, cozy soaking tubs, and plenty of bathrooms with both. We'll ask how you really use the space and give you an honest recommendation (and maybe help end a friendly household argument).
Contact us today to schedule your bathroom remodel consultation.





